Plastic, Ceramic, or Real? The Environmental Impacts of Halloween Pumpkins

Image of two orange pumpkins. Bushwick Bites. Exploring the Local Food Scene and Sustainable Initiatives in Brooklyn's Hippest Neighborhood. Bushwick Bites: Brooklyn’s fastest-growing food publication.

Halloween has long been steeped in tradition, from spooky costumes to candy corn and haunted houses. Perhaps the most iconic of all these symbols is the pumpkin, often carved with intricate designs and illuminated from within. As the ambiance of glowing jack-o-lanterns fills the autumn nights, a question arises: which is the more environmentally friendly option—plastic, ceramic, or a genuine pumpkin?

The tradition of carving pumpkins can be traced back to ancient Celtic celebrations. Originally, turnips or potatoes were hollowed out and carved with haunting faces to ward off evil spirits during Samhain, a festival marking the end of the harvest season. As Irish and Scottish immigrants brought these customs to America, they adopted the native pumpkin. Not only was the pumpkin more abundant, but its larger size and softer flesh made it easier to carve than turnips, cementing its status as the go-to Halloween decoration in the United States.

Now, centuries later, while the genuine pumpkin remains a classic choice, alternatives like plastic and ceramic pumpkins have gained popularity. Each has its merits, but if environmental concerns weigh heavily on your mind, it’s worth exploring the pros and cons of each option.

Real Pumpkins:

The authenticity of a real pumpkin is hard to beat. They’re biodegradable and compostable, making their environmental footprint relatively low—provided they’re disposed of correctly. However, the agriculture behind pumpkin farming, like any farming, requires water, land, and often pesticides. If pumpkins are farmed using unsustainable practices, their environmental impact can be considerable.

Plastic Pumpkins:

Plastic pumpkins have the advantage of durability. They can be reused year after year, which can seem like an eco-friendly option. However, the production of plastic involves polluting processes and contributes to the global plastic waste issue. These pumpkins can take hundreds of years to decompose in landfills. That said, a middle ground is emerging: thrift stores. More environmentally conscious individuals have started buying second-hand plastic pumpkins, reducing the demand for new ones and giving old decorations a new lease on life.

Ceramic Pumpkins:

Ceramics bring an artisan touch to your Halloween decorations. They’re sturdier than real pumpkins and can be reused annually. While the production of ceramics has its environmental impacts, including the energy-intensive firing process, they don’t pose the same long-term environmental issues as plastic. If they break, they can return to the earth more easily than plastic, albeit not as swiftly as real pumpkins.

Another sustainable approach gaining traction is the practice of passing down decorations through generations. Family heirlooms can include ceramic pumpkins, which not only reduces the environmental impact but also adds a layer of sentimentality to the holiday.

For those who deeply appreciate the authenticity of real pumpkins but want to approach the tradition with an environmental mindset, there’s a solution: sourcing sustainably grown pumpkins or growing your own. After Halloween, instead of throwing them away, pumpkins can be composted or used in cooking, ensuring that no part of the pumpkin goes to waste.

When making a decision, consider the longevity of your choice. If you’ll use a plastic or ceramic pumpkin for many years, it might be a justifiable choice from an environmental standpoint, especially if sourced second-hand. On the other hand, if you love the ritual of picking out a fresh pumpkin each year, aim for locally-grown, organic options.

Ultimately, the “best” choice is a personal one, guided by individual values. With the environment in mind, there are sustainable pathways with any of these options, whether it’s committing to reusing a decoration for years, supporting sustainable agriculture, or redefining traditions with thrift store finds and cherished family heirlooms. Halloween is a celebration of creativity, and with a bit of thought, it’s entirely possible to have a festive celebration that honors both the spirit of the holiday and the health of our planet.

Author: Marcus Lee